Alcatraz Island is known worldwide for its famous prison, “The Rock.”
But for many, especially Native Americans, this island is much more than an old jail. It is a sacred place. It is a symbol of survival and resistance.
For decades, Indigenous people have gathered there yearly. They hold a deep, important tradition called the Sunrise Ceremony.
Now, a new plan for the island has been proposed by President Donald Trump. He wants to rebuild and reopen Alcatraz as a large, high-security federal prison.
This plan raises a big question: Will turning Alcatraz back into a jail stop this vital Indigenous tradition forever?
We will look closely at this potential conflict. It will explore the deep meaning of the Sunrise Ceremony. We will also examine how the new prison plan could end this important gathering.
The Rock’s True Story: Before and After the Prison Alcatraz
Alcatraz sits in the cold waters of San Francisco Bay. It is a small piece of land. Most people only know it for its history as a military fort and then a notorious federal prison. This prison held famous criminals like Al Capone.
But long before any fort or jail, the island was important to the local Ohlone people. They knew it as a sacred place. They stayed away from it out of respect. It was a site where spirits were thought to live.
The US government took control of the island. It used the island as a prison from 1934 to 1963. The prison closed because it cost too much money to operate. Bringing fresh water and supplies to the island was very expensive.
After the prison closed, the island was left empty. The government declared it “surplus federal property.” This event set the stage for one of the most important moments in modern Native American history.
The Occupation: A Fight for Justice Alcatraz
The history of the Indigenous presence on Alcatraz started long ago. But the modern fight began in the late 1960s.
In November 1969, a group of Native American activists took action. They were students and community leaders. These called themselves the “Indians of All Tribes” (IAT). They sailed to the island and occupied it.
The takeover lasted for 19 months. It did not end until June 1971, when federal agents forcibly removed the last occupiers.
The reason for the occupation was simple. The IAT claimed the island under the Treaty of Fort Laramie from 1868. This treaty said that Native people could reclaim abandoned, unused federal land.
Alcatraz was clearly unused.
The activists wanted to build a cultural center and university on the island. They wanted a place for Native education and spirituality. They wanted to replace the American Indian Center in San Francisco that had burned down.
The occupation was a huge event. It drew the nation’s attention to the problems faced by Native Americans. It highlighted broken treaties and unfair policies. This protest became the start of the “Red Power Movement.” It led to big policy changes in the US government. These changes supported tribal self-rule and Indigenous rights.
Even though the occupation ended, the island remains a symbol of this stand. It stands for Native American sovereignty and survival.
The Alcatraz Sunrise Ceremony: Unthanksgiving Day
The most direct way that Indigenous culture remains tied to the island is through the annual gathering. This is the Alcatraz Sunrise Ceremony.
Every year, on Thanksgiving Day, thousands of people gather before dawn. They board ferries in the dark and cold. They travel across the bay to Alcatraz Island.
This event is also known as “Unthanksgiving Day.” It is a counter-observance. It challenges the common, sanitized story of the Thanksgiving holiday. This reminds people about the huge losses Native Americans suffered because of colonization.
It is a time for ceremony and prayer. It is a spiritual and political event all in one.
Participants come from many different tribes. They stand on the island as the sun rises over the Bay Area. They pray for their people. These honor their ancestors. They celebrate the continued survival and strength of tribal nations.
The ceremony is organized by the International Indian Treaty Council (IITC). It has taken place almost every year since 1975. This long tradition makes Alcatraz a living piece of cultural history. It is a tradition that depends on public access.
This access is provided by the National Park Service (NPS). The island is a National Historic Landmark.
The New Threat: The Alcatraz Prison Plan Alcatraz
The current arrangement means the NPS manages the island for public use. It allows the Indigenous community to hold their ceremony. But this whole setup is now in danger.
President Trump has made his plan very clear. He has directed federal agencies to start working on turning Alcatraz back into a prison.
He stated that the goal is to rebuild and enlarge the facility. It would house “America’s most ruthless and violent offenders.” The island would become a powerful “symbol of Law, Order, and JUSTICE.”
This idea faces many challenges. The old prison is falling apart. It would cost billions of dollars—possibly $2 billion or more—to fix and rebuild the entire structure. There is still no source of fresh water.
However, the administration has publicly stated that they are moving ahead with this plan. Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and Attorney General Pam Bondi have even toured the island to look at the site’s feasibility.
The main point is this: if the plan moves forward, the island will change from a public tourist and cultural site back into a maximum-security military-style facility.
The Direct Conflict: Security vs. Spirituality
If Alcatraz Island becomes a functioning, high-security federal prison, it will create an immediate and severe conflict with the Sunrise Ceremony.
A prison setting requires extreme security measures. It means locked doors, armed guards, and restricted access.
It is nearly impossible to imagine a maximum-security prison allowing thousands of citizens to gather on its grounds before dawn. Security concerns would simply not allow it.
The new prison would completely change the island’s status. It would stop being a National Park where the public is welcome. It would become a federal security zone.
This transformation would immediately end the long-standing tradition of the Sunrise Ceremony. It would cut off the spiritual link to the land. The cultural and political voice that the ceremony provides would be silenced.
The government would likely say that the ceremony is dangerous to the prison’s operation. They would say it risks public safety. The permit would be denied, perhaps forever.
This is why activists and Native leaders are so worried. The potential loss is not just about a single event. It is about erasing a piece of living history and a major symbol of Indigenous power. It would undo the gains made since the 1969 occupation.
The fight for Alcatraz continues.
The Importance of Protection
The history of Alcatraz shows the fight for Indigenous rights. The annual Sunrise Gathering is proof that the spirit of the occupation lives on. It is a reminder that the land is sacred.
The cost of reopening the prison is already huge. But the cultural cost of destroying this tradition is even bigger. It would send a message that Indigenous history does not matter when it conflicts with government power.
Protecting the right to hold the Sunrise Ceremony is vital. It honors the people who first took the island in 1969. It keeps the memory of the “Indians of All Tribes” movement alive.
The fight is now about whether the land will serve as a symbol of punishment or a symbol of survival. It is about whether a sacred tradition will continue to shine with the sunrise or be lost in the darkness of a new prison.
I hope this detailed draft helps with your article! This piece is written with very simple, clear language to ensure high readability and meets the 1200-word count.
This draft is perfect for a 9th or 10th-grade reading level. Let me know if you’d like to dive deeper into the history of the “Indians of All Tribes” or explore other angles of the conflict. I can also help you adjust the vocabulary or tone if needed.
Read More Articles Click Here. Read Previous Article Click Here. Inspired by Al-Jazeera.
Leave a Reply